The Big Handshake 2026: What Chicago Taught Me About Loyalty

3 min read
Nov 18, 2026, 3:14:39 PM

I just got back from The Big Handshake in Chicago with a notebook full of observations. Across very different industries, from restaurants and software to resorts, grocery and pro sports, three themes kept returning. Data is the foundation of every great program. Loyalty must go above and beyond points and tiers. And engagement and redemption only create value when they are relevant and timely. Each maps closely to the work we do every day at Carlton One Engagement.

  1. Data is where loyalty starts
  2. Loyalty that goes above and beyond
  3. Relevant engagement, redeemed in the moment

The strongest programs are built with their members, not just for them. After 15 years, Panera Bread reimagined MyPanera, putting member insights at the centre of its relaunch. Catherine Thacker, Panera's Vice President of Customer Engagement and Digital Marketing, shared how her team challenged the status quo and turned feedback into action for roughly 70 million members. Listening at that scale isn't a research exercise; it's a design principle.

Microsoft's direct-to-consumer team tested a bold premise: you don't need a loyalty program to build loyalty. As outlined by Danielle Yedinak, Senior Director of Digital Experiences, stepping back from a product-first mindset and leading with the customer, they showed how zero-party data, shared willingly by customers, reveals their needs, motivations and behaviours. That understanding becomes loyalty mechanics built directly into CRM, with no points-and-tiers structure required. CRM and loyalty are converging fast.

The conversation then turned to AI, framed not as hype but as a lens on trust. When audiences question what's real, authenticity is what earns loyalty.

One of my favourite sessions paired two brands with opposite problems and the same goal. Great Wolf Lodge is low frequency, high feeling. Families visit once or twice a year, save for months and remember the trip for years. In a category where frequency-based thinking simply doesn't apply, Dave Van Saun, Vice President of CRM and Ancillary, grew the program to nearly 5 million members in three years and lifted repeat visits by 18%; a key driver being the second return visit.

ADUSA is the mirror image: high frequency, low feeling. Grocery customers show up every week and the data runs deep, but loyalty is transactional. Give me my discount and let me move on. Emily Mikus, Senior Director of Loyalty Strategy, is tackling the harder half, turning weekly habit into real emotional loyalty. Her point was blunt: most programs never get there because the goal is too vague to act on. "Retain customers" is not a strategy.

Together, it's the same challenge from both directions. One brand is adding frequency to feeling; the other is adding feeling to frequency.

Partnerships got the same candid treatment. Partners bring you members; that's the easy part. Drawing on airline examples, Kevin Butler, Principal of MileagePlus Partner Operations at United Airlines, argued acquisition alone won't sustain a partnership. Lasting ones are real revenue streams, with a value exchange that pays off for both sides long after launch.

Real-time loyalty sounds simple in theory. Many programs have enabled real-time earning, redemption and personalized offers, yet still struggle to deliver them when the customer is deciding. The barrier isn't strategy; it's infrastructure. Payment rails, POS technology, issuer systems and loyalty platforms must all work together seamlessly; a lofty ambition.

Payments are no longer just the end of a transaction. They're the moment loyalty either creates impact or misses the opportunity. As AI and agentic experiences reshape engagement, instant redemption and intelligent decisioning become foundational. Without those rails, agentic loyalty can't become a reality.

The Cleveland Cavaliers’ Jeremy Halek, Vice President of Consumer Marketing, showed what relevance looks like across a long NBA season. Some fans are engaged, some have drifted, some have never joined. Rather than building more segments and sends, Cavs Rewards and Blings.io’ Yosef Peterseil, COO and Co-Founder, created one interactive video that personalized itself the moment each fan opened it. Treated as participants rather than viewers, fans averaged nearly eight interactions each, a rare result for email and as a result, the organization has industry-leading in-game experience and engagement.

CarltonOne accepting the challenge
The message from Chicago was clear. Loyalty is earned when data informs every interaction, when programs create real emotional value, and when rewards arrive at the moment they matter most. Redemption is where a program keeps its promise, and it's often the moment members remember. At CarltonOne, that's our exact focus: helping organizations turn member insight into rewards and experiences that feel personal, relevant, and immediate. I left Chicago more convinced than ever that this is where the next era of loyalty will be won, and as Chief Revenue Officer, I’m excited to help drive this forward.